The Mistletoe Murder - Book Group Discussion Thread

12 watchers

1
2
3
4
Next
Last

McGoohan Dec 2017 8:40am, 8 Dec 2017 32206 posts	0 McGoohan I'm sorry Miss Eltoe I am for real Didn't mean to make your daughter cry I apologise a trillion times So sang Andre 3000 of Outkast. He'd just read The Mistletoe Murder and Other Stories by P D James. He's given us his review, now give us yours. Whatcha think?
GregP Dec 2017 8:58am, 8 Dec 2017 97704 posts	0 GregP Do we review a story at a time or do we wait and review the book as a whole?
McGoohan Dec 2017 9:01am, 8 Dec 2017 32208 posts	0 McGoohan Whatever provides buoyancy for your sailing vessel
GregP Dec 2017 9:18am, 8 Dec 2017 97706 posts	0 GregP Fine. Then I can exclusively reveal that I have read the first story and was entirely whelmed.
McGoohan Dec 2017 9:19am, 8 Dec 2017 32209 posts	0 McGoohan Should I have done 4 polls? So we could assign degrees of whelming to each one?
GregP Dec 2017 9:32am, 8 Dec 2017 97708 posts	0 GregP On a three card GT/BT/T (Good Thing / Bad Thing / Thing) scale it was definitely A Thing.
GregP Dec 2017 9:36am, 8 Dec 2017 97709 posts	0 GregP On a five card system (VBT/BT/T/GT/VGT) it still ranks a Thing, actually.
Badger Dec 2017 3:48pm, 8 Dec 2017 8894 posts	0 Badger I am reading story 1. I just have to step in here to admire "given half a chance, he would have pawed me and assessed my second hand value." Clever.
GregP Dec 2017 8:41am, 9 Dec 2017 97769 posts	0 GregP I have finished story two and remain whelmed.
GregP Dec 2017 8:43am, 9 Dec 2017 97770 posts	0 GregP [the book will always score well with me because of the charming events of last Saturday morning, with Badgo and Serrers alerting me to the choice on twitter when I was within sight of Ye Bintshoppe]

1
2
3
4
Next
Last

About This Thread

Maintained by McGoohan

I'm sorry Miss Eltoe
I am for real
Didn't mean to make your daughter cry
I apologise a trillion times

The place, the in place to review December 2017's Book Group choice. Do it or do not do. There is no tripe.

Related Threads

bookgroup
books
crimefic

Flat as a pancake?

We've collected thousands of your reviews from events, and worked out which races give you the best chance of a fast time!

Check the lists

UTMOST

Beat your league rivals to gain weekly promotion. Compete at every distance from a mile to a marathon.

Join the league

Marathon Prediction

We delve deeper to give you greater insights when working out your goal marathon time.

Get your prediction

Fetch Everyone Running Club

Join our UKA-affiliated club for event discounts, London Marathon ballot places, the chance to get funded for coaching qualifications, and a warm feeling inside.

Click here for more