Elmet - Jan 2022 Book Group discussion thread

8 watchers
31 Jan
10:57am, 31 Jan 2022
5660 posts
  • 0
Finished this last night. I quite enjoyed it, even though some of the subject matter wasn't very palatable.

There were a lot of unanswered questions: what happened to the mother? who was Vivien? why was the money stolen? what happened to the dogs? is Cathy alive? I guess these are intentional as the story was told from Daniel's perspective and he didn't know.
31 Jan
9:16pm, 31 Jan 2022
21564 posts
  • 0
Indeed, did Daniel himself survive beyond the end of the story?
26 Feb
11:41pm, 26 Feb 2022
25415 posts
  • 0
I enjoyed this for the first third. Then it started to feel like I was starting to wade through gloom and foreboding and that the story was driven by A Message From The Author For Which The Story Was A Mere Vehicle. I’m not so keen on that and I stalled for a month. I finished it off tonight and on consideration quite enjoyed it. Gave it a 7 because it put me off reading for a bit
27 Feb
7:33am, 27 Feb 2022
53175 posts
  • 0
Gloom and foreboding. Yes
27 Feb
8:41am, 27 Feb 2022
46642 posts
  • 0
I keep forgetting to add my bit here!

Mixed feelings towards it, TBH. It kept me reading. I wanted to know what happened next and I quite liked the writing.
It didn't bother me that the boy was far more articulate on the page than he would have been in real life. Happy to allow for poetic licence on that one.

What did irritate me was "My Daddy" which might have been more realistic than some of the other language he used but which had me thinking, "If he says My Daddy one more time I will slap his face clean off." :-)

It didn't matter to me that the book ended without me knowing their full back story or what the future held. I guess that's like life.

BUT, as others have said, I did feel it got grim for the sake of being grim at times.
My biggest beef was the big scene in the cottage where the sister comes in like a naked Terminator and wreaks all kinds of havoc and violence. At that point, it lost me. It still winds me up and this is weeks later *rolls eyes at self*

All this being said, I gave it a 7
27 Feb
10:10pm, 27 Feb 2022
25423 posts
  • 0
It was like the terminator at the end. I rather enjoyed that it was thoroughly ludicrous
28 Feb
10:41pm, 28 Feb 2022
21613 posts
  • 0
What Seren said about "A Message From The Author".

Back in the late 1950s, or maybe early 60s, someone said of the "Angry Young Men": They are postmen; they deliver messages.

Got something to say?

To join the discussion, sign in or join us.

About This Thread

Maintained by McGoohan
Elmet by Fiona Mazel-Tov as chozzen by Bint is the first book group book choice book book of 2022 and was booklisted for the Booker Book Prize.

Book a place now on this journey of bookscovery. Starting with your thoughts, herewith.

Runaround, starting.... now!

Useful Links

FE accepts no responsibility for external links. Or anything, really.

Related Threads

  • bookgroup
  • books

Heart Rate Analysis

See your heart rate training data from the last 12 months broken down in technicolour.

Flat as a pancake?

We've collected thousands of your reviews from events, and worked out which races give you the best chance of a fast time!


Beat your league rivals to gain weekly promotion. Compete at every distance from a mile to a marathon.

Marathon Prediction

We delve deeper to give you greater insights when working out your goal marathon time.

Back To Top

Free training & racing tools for runners, cyclists, swimmers & walkers.

Fetcheveryone lets you analyse your training, find races, plot routes, chat in our forum, get advice, play games - and more! Nothing is behind a paywall, and it'll stay that way thanks to our awesome community!
Get Started
Click here to join 108,756 Fetchies!
Already a Fetchie? Sign in here