Great Circle by Maggie Shipstead - July 2022 Book Group discussion
8 watchers
Aug 2022
1:20pm, 5 Aug 2022
56,132 posts
|
LindsD
And I see that I agree broadly with LD, not for the first time. And agree about the choke lit stuff, too.
|
Sep 2022
9:55am, 4 Sep 2022
26,503 posts
|
Serendippily
I felt a bit mean about this book as I enjoyed quite a lot of sections: it just felt too contrived with its different voices and vignettes. A shorter book cutting out most of the relationship conjecture and the current day actress and focussing on the journey; a period piece on womens trapped relationships, with a modern day equivalent compare and contrast if you must; a history of womens flying; a post modern piece on acting - I think I would have enjoyed better editing and separate stories more than I did the whole. But then I’m a Beryl Bainbridge fan for her ruthless clean prose (birthday boys came to mind) and this was just a bit florid overall. I found the bits with Marian and Caleb particularly weak. And enjoyed Jamie as a character. And didn’t entirely believe Ruth. And found Ed squashed in too late. And each of those sections reminded me of another, better book, as if she didn’t have the confidence to tell one story. Still enjoyed it though |
Sep 2022
10:35am, 4 Sep 2022
26,506 posts
|
Serendippily
The sex in general lost a mark for me. I do not think she described the claustrophobia of an obsessive relationship well not how you doubt yourself
|
Sep 2022
9:30pm, 4 Sep 2022
56,690 posts
|
LindsD
Agree about there being better books in there.
|
Oct 2022
8:05pm, 31 Oct 2022
6,746 posts
|
westmoors
I really enjoyed this. Normally I get annoyed with narratives that jump between timelines, but this one didn't do that. Liked how aviation facts got woven in. Not sure all the sex was necessary. Gave it a 9.
|
Related Threads
- Book Group Apr 2024
- This Is Memorial Device - Oct 2019 Book Group discussion thread Apr 2024
- Independence Day by Richard Ford - April 2024 Book Group choice Apr 2024
- The Rabbit Factor - Jan 2024 Book Group discussion Apr 2024
- The High House by Jessie Greengrass - March 2024 Fetch Book Group discussion thread Mar 2024
- Severance by Ling Ma - Feb 2024 Book Group discussion thread Feb 2024
- Book Club Archive Jan 2024
- Watling Street - Nov 2023 Book Group dicussion thread Jan 2024
- The Indisputable Existence of Santa Claus - December 2023 Book Group discussion thread Dec 2023
- Before the Coffee Gets Cold - Book Group - Oct 2023 discussion thread Nov 2023