|
Aug 2008
4:00pm, 17 Aug 2008
1,401 posts
|
abdou
Paula still finished 22nd and beat Liz Yelling on one leg. I have sympathy for Hayley Haining but anyone think she'd have done better?
|
|
Aug 2008
4:14pm, 17 Aug 2008
839 posts
|
well, paula is 34!
|
|
Aug 2008
4:18pm, 17 Aug 2008
3,686 posts
|
Paula had more chance of getting a medal than Haining, Haining was behind Yelling at London so no would be the answer
|
|
Aug 2008
4:26pm, 17 Aug 2008
15,695 posts
|
LorraineS
a fit Paula had more chance of getting a medal, but she wasn't fit ..
I doubt Yelling's result was a true one given the fall
I'm with Bill, Haining should have been running not Paula. Anybody else would have had to have proven their fitness to the British team management.
|
|
Aug 2008
4:27pm, 17 Aug 2008
519 posts
|
Widger
I agree with Jacobi, Hayley was slower than Yelling she had even less chance of a medal in my opinion.
Paula didn't rob anyone of a place. It was a place she had earnt herself, she had every right to use that place to persue her dream. If we are going to not allow any of the people to run who have no chance of a medal then surely why are we letting any of our Male's take part in the 100m?
If we are goingto say that Paula wasn't allowed to take part in the maraton because of injury then should we not say that Kelly Sotherton shouldn't have been allowed to take part because her training has been dogged by kidney problems.
|
|
Aug 2008
4:58pm, 17 Aug 2008
1,085 posts
|
paul a
If Haining was good enough she would have earned her place like everyone else.
|
|
Aug 2008
5:01pm, 17 Aug 2008
3,688 posts
|
Paula deserves the place on the basis of her past and the fact that she holds the WR, she is one of the most successful athletes we have ever had. With the greatest respect to Haining, Paula (even not 100%) is in a different class
|
|
Aug 2008
5:39pm, 17 Aug 2008
492 posts
|
Doctor K
She clearly wasn't fit so one must question why she ran -it doesn't fit with the decision to "fitness" test Jo Pavey before her 5000m . She is a top class marathon runner but I'm afraid all the hype and publicity and the attention to her demise overshadowed the performance of our other athletes
|
|
Aug 2008
5:42pm, 17 Aug 2008
1,086 posts
|
paul a
Better to start and have a go than not bother at all.
|
|
Aug 2008
5:44pm, 17 Aug 2008
1,402 posts
|
abdou
Mara Yamauchi deserved more praise for a great run but the balance of coverage is hardly Radcliffe's fault.
|
